• Home
  • Our People
    • Christine Burns
    • David T. Barton
    • Alison Pulaski Carter
    • Alexandra Miller
    • Cecilia N. Nieto
  • Practice Areas
    • Employment Litigation
    • Employment Law Advice
    • Restrictive Covenants
    • Employment Contracts
    • Compliance
  • BurnsBarton Blog
  • Get Started
  • Contact and Directions

Ninth Circuit Takes an Expansive View of Whistleblower Protection Under Cal. Lab. Code § 1102.5

November 04, 2022
by David Barton
0 Comment

Aaron Kilgore worked as an environmental consultant on a project his employer was completing for the U.S. Army Reserve Command. He complained to his supervisor, and to a representative from the Army, that he believed the environmental assessment he had been asked to prepare was illegal. He was fired shortly thereafter and brought a claim under Cal. Lab. Code § 1102.5 (the “Whistleblower Statute”).

Kilgore’s employer, SpecPro, argued, among other things, that Kilgore’s report was not protected because Kilgore’s supervisor was not a person “with authority … to investigate, discover, or correct the violation or noncompliance” as required under the Whistleblower Statute. Similarly, SpecPro also argued that Kilgore’s report to the Army officer was part of Kilgore’s “normal duties” of employment – and not, therefore, protected activity. Finally, SpecPro argued that Kilgore could have no reasonable belief that a violation of the law occurred because his report was “forward looking” and could not, therefore, be a report about past illegal activity. The District Court agreed with these arguments and granted summary judgment to SpecPro.

The Ninth Circuit disagreed and reversed. It held that disclosures to “a person with authority over the employee” was sufficient to garner statutory protections. It also rejected the “normal duties” argument, finding that whistleblower activities are protected under the plain language of the statute “regardless of whether disclosing the information is part of the employee’s normal duties.” And finally, the court ruled that Kilgore had a reasonable belief that his report was illegal when it failed to consider prior events – even if the report was intended to be forward looking.

In short, the Ninth Circuit has taken an expansive view of California’s Whistleblower Statute and California employers should carefully investigate all claims of illegality (regardless of who receives the claim) and evaluate whether employees who make those claims (regardless of their job duties) are protected under the law.

Killgore v. Specpro Pro. Servs., LLC, 51 F.4th 973 (9th Cir. 2022) (October 20, 2022)

About the Author
David T. Barton is a veteran employment lawyer who has dedicated his career to the protection of good employers. He takes a common sense and practical approach to the law, helping employers find ways to accomplish their goals while avoiding legal liability. Mr. Barton is also a noted speaker and trainer and uses his presentation skills to the advantage of his clients whether in training or in the courtroom.
Social Share
  • google-share

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

*
*

Contact BurnsBarton Attorneys

Please call or email any of our attorneys. We’ll talk with you about your needs and design a plan to accomplish your goals. Initial consultations are generally free and we offer flat-fee and alternative billing options for interested clients. Our rates are lower than the large firms we left, but it is our billing policies and practices that make us the most cost-efficient solution for employers in the Southwest.  
 
    Call 602-753-4500

About BurnsBarton PLC

BurnsBarton is a woman-owned business made up of big firm attorneys who have gone small to provide better client service at a lower cost. Our team has the horsepower necessary to handle big cases, while remaining committed to excellent client service. We focus on what we do best: advising and defending employers efficiently, effectively, and successfully. In short, we have “Big Law” experience, with better, more economical service.

Mission Statement

We protect good employers from all types of employment claims. We win cases, and we do so in the most cost-efficient manner possible. We work with the best people on the planet.  

certified-womens-business-enterprise-logo-small

Disclaimer

The information on this web site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should contact an attorney for advice on your individual situation. Contacting BurnsBarton PLC does not create an attorney-client relationship.

 

Address: 2201 E. Camelback Road Suite 360 Phoenix, AZ 85016 Phone: 602-753-4500
© 2012 - 2023 BurnsBarton PLC